7 Comments

Hobbes gets the term “Law” in Laws of Nature from us lawyers . Natural science laws do , too . The legal method of proving truths based on evidence from human witnesses is the model they are analogizing to. I teach this to my anthropology classes .

Notice Lenin, Fidel Castro, Nelson Mandela, Abraham Lincoln were lawyers . Marx was studying law.

Expand full comment

It’s almost always the case that any discussion of natural lawfulness is rooted in analogies from social lawfulness. The cosmic lawfulness Anaximander described (for the first time ever) was a projection of societal lawfulness onto the cosmos.

Expand full comment

I didn’t know that

Expand full comment

However , Hobbes is exactly wrong on the original human nature when he claims it’s a war-of-all-against-all, that is _ not_ communist . Human nature , original human society in the Stone Age is Communist , sharing , “ from each according to ability; to each according to need .”

Expand full comment

Yes, we agree.

Expand full comment

The U.S. Liberal reforms of the last 90 years are an immanent critique of US capitalism. U.S. Socialism is becoming out of accumulation of rational reform-critiques of US capitalism won by the Wage-labor class in electoral politics - the New Deal, the Great Society /War on Poverty/ Civil Rights laws , Obamacare , Bidenomics. Won by Working class practical-critical , that is revolutionary, activity ( see Theses on Feuerbach).

Expand full comment